Blog

Forbidden foods: why banning a food makes you want it more

Tell yourself you are never eating chocolate again and notice what happens. By mid afternoon it is all you can think about. That is not a lack of willpower. It is a very common way for the mind to react.

Psychologists call it reactance. When something feels like a threat to our freedom, we push back, and the thing we have been told we cannot have becomes more attractive. Diets are full of these threats. In my sessions I see it all the time with people who have spent years on and off food rules. The rules were meant to help, and somehow food ended up taking more room in their head than ever.

How a rule turns a food into an obsession

A banned food stops being just food. It becomes a test, a reward and a small rebellion all at once. Every time you walk past it you are reminded that you cannot have it, and each reminder adds a little more charge.

Then something happens, a long day or a difficult conversation, and the rule breaks. Because the food was forbidden, one biscuit feels like failure, and failure often turns into ‘I might as well finish the packet’. Afterwards comes guilt, then a stricter rule, and the circle starts again.

This is diet fatigue. Policing yourself all day is tiring, and for many people that tiredness wears them down more than hunger ever does.

  • The rule makes the food special
  • You think about it more
  • One bite feels like failure
  • Guilt leads to a stricter rule

From ‘not allowed’ to ‘not needed right now’

The shift I work towards in hypnosis is simple to describe. Instead of ‘I’m not allowed that’, the thought becomes ‘I could have that if I wanted. I just don’t want it right now.’ The food is still there. Nothing has been taken away. That alone takes much of the fight out of it.

Alongside that, I like to swap good and bad food for a more useful question: is this useful to me at the moment? A slice of cake at a family birthday can be a perfectly sensible choice. A third bag of crisps eaten standing at the fridge usually is not. The question is about you and the moment, rather than the food being wicked.

Many people find their body’s own signals become easier to hear once the rules quieten down. Hunger, fullness and real enjoyment are all information. Rules tend to drown them out.

Something to try: the permission sentence

Next time you catch yourself staring down a food you have banned, pause before you either resist it or give in. Say to yourself, quietly: ‘I can have this if I want it.’ Then ask: ‘Do I actually want it, right now?’

The answer might be yes, and that is fine. Eat it slowly, sitting down, and notice what it really tastes like. Or you might find the urge softens once nobody is telling you no. Either way you have made a choice instead of fighting a rule.

If you want to go further, try it with the food you have banned for longest. You do not need to eat it. Just notice what changes in your body when ‘never’ becomes ‘if I want’. For a lot of people there is a small drop in tension, like a held breath being let out. That is the rule starting to lose its grip.

Episodes to listen to

These three sessions tackle food rules from different angles. Start with the forbidden fruit if banned foods are your main sticking point.

Weight Loss Hypnosis: Resisting the Temptations of the Forbidden Fruit

28 min, free on The Hypnotist Podcast

I use the Garden of Eden as a picture of plenty: a garden full of food, one tree you are told not to touch, and suddenly that tree is all you want. The session turns forbidden foods into optional ones and replaces right and wrong with whether a choice is useful to you. The aim is to take the guilt and drama out of cravings.

Good if you find that banning a food only makes you want it more.

Listen on The Hypnotist Podcast

Intuitive Weight Loss

Free on The Hypnotist Podcast

This session is about reconnecting with your own sense of hunger, movement and enjoyment after years of mixed messages. In trance you picture your conscious and unconscious mind as two islands joined by a bridge, with messengers passing between them. How you feel after eating is treated as useful feedback, and any change in shape as a side effect of better choices rather than the target.

Good if you are worn out by diet rules and want to trust yourself again.

Listen on The Hypnotist Podcast

Identity-Based Weight Loss: Hypnosis to Reprogram Food Choices and Reduce Cravings

36 min, free on The Hypnotist Podcast

Here you build a picture of the person you want to be by blending the best of who you have been before, then watch that person make food choices from identity rather than restriction. Each choice is treated as a vote for that identity, and a slip is met with a calm reset instead of shame.

Good if you find one slip usually turns into giving up altogether.

Listen on The Hypnotist Podcast

Common questions

Why do I crave foods more when I’m on a diet?

Restriction tends to make a food feel scarce and special, and the mind pays more attention to things it believes it cannot have. Many people find cravings ease once the food is no longer forbidden and becomes an ordinary choice.

Should I ban sugar or junk food completely?

Some people do well with clear limits, but for many a total ban sets up the cycle of craving, slip and guilt. I usually help people focus on choosing well most of the time instead of living by strict rules. If you have a medical reason to avoid a food, follow your GP or dietitian’s advice.

Can hypnosis help with food rules and diet fatigue?

Hypnosis works with habits, feelings and attention, so it can help you relate to food with less pressure and more choice. It is not a diet and it does not replace medical advice, but many people find it gives them a calmer place to start from.

Please read

Hypnosis works with habits, feelings and attention. It is not medical treatment and does not replace your GP. If you have, or think you may have, an eating disorder, or you are pregnant, diabetic or taking weight-loss medicine, please speak to your GP first. Beat, the UK eating disorder charity, is on 0808 801 0677. The podcast sessions are for adults: listen somewhere comfortable, never while driving. If cycles of restricting and then eating a lot feel like more than a habit, or you feel out of control around food, the right first step is your GP or Beat, the UK eating disorder charity, on 0808 801 0677.

Where to go from here

Listen on The Hypnotist Podcast

Every session above is free to hear on The Hypnotist Podcast, along with more than 200 other weight and eating episodes.

Start listening

Browse all weight episodes

Is hypnosis right for you?

Take my free four minute suitability test. You get an honest answer about whether hypnotherapy is likely to help with your goals, and how.

Take the suitability test

Prefer to talk it through? Book a consultation call and use code SLIM at checkout for half price: £24.50 instead of £49 (or $29.50 outside the UK).

More on this topic: cravings and snacking.

More from the blog

See all guides